Bank of Canada Raises Its Rate to 2.5%: Why I Think It Was a Mistake and What It Means for Toronto Buyers

This post is based on my video published on October 28, 2026, the day the Bank of Canada announced its rate decision. It reflects my own opinion and the data as I understood it that day, and it is general information, not financial advice. Check current rates and speak with a mortgage professional about your own situation.

The Bank of Canada just raised its benchmark rate by a quarter point to 2.5%. I believe this is a mistake, and in this post I explain the three reasons why. I also lay out the two reasons the bank felt it had to act, because it is fair to understand both sides, and then I look at what this means if you are buying or selling a home in Toronto.

What the Bank of Canada did

The central bank raised its overnight rate by 0.25 percentage points to 2.5%. That is the benchmark that sets variable-rate mortgages and lines of credit, which follow the prime rate set by the banks. Fixed mortgage rates are different, because they follow bond yields. In early September, prime was 4.45%, so if the banks pass the full increase through, prime would move up to roughly 4.70%.

Mistake 1: inflation is not as hot as the headline

The latest inflation figure came in at 3.1%. But if you look at the detail in Statistics Canada's report and strip out gasoline prices, inflation was about 2.2%. Core inflation, which removes volatile items, came in at about 1.8% to 1.9%, which is well within the Bank of Canada's target range.

In other words, the headline number is being pushed up by energy. When most of the pressure is coming from gasoline, a rate hike is a blunt tool, because higher interest rates do not lower the price of oil. They mostly slow down spending on everything else.

Mistake 2: jobs are being lost

With the Canada and US trade war, unemployment numbers have been increasing. Over August and September, Canada lost about 110,000 jobs, and more job losses are coming around the corner. You may have heard about the Stelco layoffs and the ripple effect they will have on the companies that support those big factories. That means more potential unemployment is on the way.

This is the sign of an economy that is stuck. It is not growing because of what is happening between Canada and the US, and raising the cost of borrowing in that environment adds pressure on households and businesses that are already struggling.

Mistake 3: the GDP number is flattered by oil

Canada's GDP has grown by more than expected, but I want to be specific about why. Before the end of February 2026, Alberta's budget projected a deficit of about $9 billion at the oil prices of the time. After the Middle East crisis that has been ongoing for many months, Alberta is projected to have a surplus of over $2 billion. That is an $11 billion swing for one province. As more revenue comes in from oil sales, it lifts the overall Canadian GDP numbers.

If you take out the higher oil prices, the reality is that the Canadian economy has not been growing. It is struggling and stuck because of the trade war. So a decent-looking GDP figure may be masking weakness in the rest of the economy, particularly the manufacturing sector in Ontario.

Why the Bank of Canada felt it had to hike

Even though I disagree with the decision, I believe there are two reasons the bank went ahead.

1. The gap with the US Federal Reserve

The difference between the Canadian benchmark rate and the US Federal Reserve's rate directly affects the exchange rate. For a while now the Canadian dollar has been weak, at roughly $1.40 to $1.42 Canadian per US dollar. That inherently raises the price of goods, because whatever we import is paid for in US dollars. If the Federal Reserve keeps raising rates to address inflation while the Bank of Canada stays unchanged or cuts because the economy is slowing, the gap widens, the Canadian dollar gets weaker and that causes inflation down the line. This is one reason the bank had to play catch-up with the Federal Reserve.

2. The memory of the pandemic

I call this the pandemic PTSD. You may recall that the Governor of the Bank of Canada, the same person in the job today, described inflation as transitory. The bank sat on the sidelines, waited and waited until it was too late, and then had to raise rates aggressively and pretty much bring the economy to a halt. I believe the bank does not want to repeat that, so it moved earlier this time.

What this means if you are buying or selling in Toronto

A quarter-point change is small on its own. On a $500,000 variable-rate balance, a quarter point adds roughly $1,250 a year in interest. The bigger effect is on confidence. In recent months I have talked with qualified buyers who paused their purchase because of the economy, not because of their mortgage approval. A rate hike adds another reason to wait, and it can also make sellers hesitate, which tightens supply. Because the Toronto market is local, the effect will differ by neighbourhood and property type.

If you are a buyer

  • Get pre-approved, and ask your lender how a further increase would change your payment.

  • If you are choosing between variable and fixed, remember that variable follows prime and fixed follows bond yields.

  • Run your budget on one income if you can, so a job change does not become a crisis.

If you are a seller

  • Price to current conditions and do not wait for a perfect announcement.

  • Expect some buyers to sit on the sidelines, so presentation and pricing matter more.

What this means for you

  • The Bank of Canada raised its rate by 0.25 points to 2.5%.

  • In my view, the hike is a mistake because inflation excluding gasoline is lower, jobs are being lost and growth depends on oil.

  • The bank likely acted because of the gap with the US Federal Reserve and its experience in the pandemic.

  • Variable-rate borrowers feel the change first, and fixed rates follow bond yields.

  • Focus on your own numbers rather than one headline.

Frequently asked questions

What did the Bank of Canada do on October 28, 2026?

It raised its benchmark rate by a quarter point to 2.5%.

Why do you think the rate hike was a mistake?

Inflation excluding gasoline was about 2.2% and core inflation was about 1.8% to 1.9%. Canada lost about 110,000 jobs in August and September, and GDP growth is being supported by higher oil prices.

Why did the bank raise rates anyway?

To keep pace with the US Federal Reserve and protect the Canadian dollar, and because of the experience of the pandemic, when it waited too long to act.

Will my mortgage payment go up?

If you have a variable-rate mortgage or a line of credit tied to prime, your rate may rise. Fixed-rate mortgages are priced off bond yields and are not changed directly by the announcement.

Should I wait to buy a home in Toronto?

It depends on your own numbers, your job security and your budget. Get pre-approved, know your payment at higher rates and avoid decisions based on a single headline.

Book a free consultation

If you want to talk through how rates affect your plans, I would be happy to help. Book a free consultation using the contact page.