7 Home Upgrades Toronto Sellers Regret (and One Can Kill Your Deal at Inspection)

This post is based on my video published on November 15, 2026. The market figures I mention were current when I recorded it and will have moved since. The opinions are mine, and this is general information, not legal, financial or renovation advice. Speak with a lawyer, your municipality and a contractor before making changes to your home.

If you are planning to renovate before you list your house for sale, you could spend tens of thousands of dollars that buyers will never pay you back. When I recorded this video there were about 9,526 homes for sale in Toronto, and they were selling for roughly 98% of the asking price. Buyers have choice, and they are not willing to pay extra for your taste.

Here are the seven upgrades I see cost sellers the most money, and number four can kill your deal at the home inspection.

1. Over-personalizing the renovation

The first mistake I see is over-personalizing. I was with buyer clients who went down to the basement, where there was an elaborate bar. It appealed to the homeowner. It did not appeal to the potential buyers. Another example was a sauna downstairs. Some people want one, but most people do not. I have had buyers purchase a house and then remove the sauna and turn the space into storage.

Bold designs that are tailored to one person's taste are not necessarily functional for anyone else. Designing a home for your own use is good. Just keep in mind that when you sell, you want the features to appeal to the largest number of buyers, especially in a market where buyers have the upper hand in negotiations.

2. Over-improving for the street

The second mistake is spending more than the street can support. Take a semi-detached house in a pocket where semis sell for around $1.1 million to $1.2 million. If the homeowner puts $250,000 to $300,000 of renovations into that house, it is very difficult to recover that money at resale.

There is an exception. If you intend to live in the house for a very long time, the numbers can make sense for you. I have seen pockets where it is justified. In some areas, owners of semis and detached houses are adding a third storey for extra capacity instead of selling and buying a larger house. In those pockets there is significant investment going into the homes. The key is to know what your area can sustain from a resale perspective, and the best way to find out is to look at what similar houses on your street have actually sold for.

3. Removing a bedroom

I have seen houses that used to have three bedrooms where one bedroom was combined into the primary bedroom to create a walk-in closet. For the homeowner it is great from a functionality standpoint. For the value of the property it is a problem, because buyers search by the number of bedrooms.

The same goes for permanently turning a bedroom into an office. If it stays as is, with a desk and some shelving, that is fine. Permanent changes that remove a bedroom reduce the value of the house. If you need extra space, use the basement for an office or whatever else you need, but do not reduce the number of bedrooms upstairs.

4. Unpermitted work, the one that can kill the deal

The fourth mistake can kill the sale of your property: unpermitted basement apartments, and renovations where structural walls were taken out. A home inspector can see where a structural wall was opened and removed and the space turned into one large open area. If there is a basement apartment with a separate entrance, a kitchen, a bathroom and a bedroom that was not permitted by the city, and the buyer needs that rental income to qualify for the mortgage, it can potentially kill the deal.

It is important to do things properly, with permits approved by the city. That helps you as the homeowner down the line when it is time to sell. If you are not sure whether work done on your house was permitted, find out before you list, not after a buyer's inspector or lawyer raises it.

5. Removing features buyers want

A good example is removing all the bathtubs. I understand that as we get older a walk-in shower is easier and safer, and that is great. From a resale perspective, though, it is good to keep at least one bathtub, because the buyer could be a young family and a bathtub is handy when you have young kids.

Another example is converting the garage into a permanent theatre or gym. It is fine if you want to use it that way yourself, but make sure it can be converted back to a garage where someone can park a car. There is a lot of value in having a garage, especially in the city.

6. An elaborate backyard project

Some neighbourhoods can justify a pool, a sauna, a cold plunge, a jacuzzi or a hot tub. The backyard is the homeowner's oasis, but it is good to keep it within reason based on what the neighbourhood can sustain from a resale perspective down the line. A buyer in a pocket where most yards are simple may see an elaborate backyard as a maintenance cost and a liability, not an added value.

7. Trendy finishes

I have seen blue and green kitchens, extremely rare materials and designs that are very trendy right now. They are not timeless. In two, three or five years those trends will change completely, and if the homeowner decides to sell then, the finishes may not appeal to a buyer. The buyer may look at them as a negative, because they will have to renovate into something more neutral.

Customizing your home to your style is great, but make sure it is timeless and could attract as many buyers as possible when it is time to sell.

Why this matters in today's market

Selling in this market can be tricky. When I recorded the video, about one out of five properties for sale was selling, which means the other four were sitting on the market, waiting to be repriced or taking significantly longer to sell. In a market like this, you do not have the luxury of a buyer who falls in love with your personal choices. The house that sells is the one that is priced right, in good condition, and easy for the most buyers to picture themselves in.

What sellers can do instead

  • Before spending anything, ask a local agent which improvements buyers on your street have actually paid for.

  • Spend on the basics: repairs, paint in neutral colours, cleaning, lighting and presentation.

  • If you have done work that was not permitted, speak with a professional about the options before listing.

  • Put back what buyers expect, such as a bedroom count, a bathtub and a usable garage, when you can do so affordably.

  • Price to the current market, not to the cost of your renovation.

What this means for you

  • Buyers have choice and are not paying extra for personal taste.

  • Know what your street can support before you spend on a renovation.

  • Keep bedroom counts, at least one bathtub and a working garage.

  • Do work with permits, because unpermitted work can kill a deal.

  • Keep finishes neutral and timeless.

Frequently asked questions

Should I renovate before selling my house in Toronto?

It depends on the street and the price point. In a market where buyers have choice, large renovations are often not paid back, so focus on repairs, neutral finishes and presentation. Ask a local agent what buyers in your pocket have paid for.

Which renovations hurt resale value the most?

The seven I see most are over-personalizing, over-improving for the street, removing a bedroom, unpermitted work, removing features buyers want, elaborate backyard projects and trendy finishes.

Can unpermitted work stop a sale?

Yes. An unpermitted basement apartment or a removed structural wall can be found at the inspection, and if the buyer needs rental income to qualify, it can potentially kill the deal.

Does removing a bedroom lower the value of a house?

It can, because buyers search by bedroom count. Using the basement for an office instead keeps the bedrooms upstairs.

Is a bathtub important when selling?

It is good to keep at least one, because many buyers are young families who value a bathtub.

Book a free consultation

If you are thinking of selling and want to know what is worth doing and what is not, I would be happy to help. Book a free consultation using the contact page.